Skip to main content

Table 3 Presentation of the results from type3 F tests and the analyses of the variance components of the herd and cow components of the clinical parameters (obs= Observer, dim=Days in Milk and par=parity).

From: Contributions to variability of clinical measures for use as indicators of udder health status in a clinical protocol

 

Fixed Effect

Random effects

Parameter

obs

dim

par

obs*dim

dim*par

obs*par

dim n

Farm

Cow

Residual

Soiling legs

0.003

-

0.002

NS

NS

NS

dim4 P = 0.002

14.0

21.7

64.3

Soiling udder

NS

-

NS

NS

NS

NS

dim4 P < 0.001

14.0

8.3

77.7

Soiling teats

0.021

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

25.9

 

74.1

Calluses hocks

-

-

-

0.009

0.006

NS

NS

24.5

25.8

49.7

Claw length

0.001

NS

0.001

NS

NS

NS

NS

21.3

 

78.7

Mange

***

NS

0.018

NS

NS

NS

NS

70.0

 

30.0

Long udder

0.003

<0.001

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

5.0

 

95.0

Withdrawn

N/C

0.066

0.008

N/C

0.016

N/C

NS

34.0

 

66.0

Asymmetric

NS

NS

0.005

NS

NS

NS

NS

10.9

 

89.1

Small udder

N/C

NS

***

N/C

NS

N/C

NS

40.1

 

59.9

Deep Udder

NS

0.044

***

NS

NS

NS

NS

35.0

 

65.0

Asym. Fore

NS

-

-

NS

0.003

NS

NS

5.9

 

94.1

Asym. Hind

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

28.3

 

71.7

Udder consist.

-

-

-

0.043

NS

0.005

dim6 P < 0.001

2.6

19.4

78.0

Oedema

-

***

NS

NS

NS

NS

dim3 P = 0.001

24.4

 

75.6

Inflammation

N/C

0.009

NS

N/C

NS

N/C

NS

9.3

 

90.7

Uddernode

N/C

0.007

0.009

N/C

NS

N/C

NS

89.4

 

10.6

Nodular tissue

N/C

NS

NS

N/C

NS

N/C

NS

53.1

 

46.9

Conical teat

N/C

N/C

N/C

N/C

N/C

N/C

N/C

38.3

 

61.7

Short teat

N/C

0.014

***

N/C

NS

N/C

NS

24.1

 

75.9

Fleshy teat

N/C

NS

N/C

N/C

N/C

N/C

NS

64.1

 

35.9

Other/long teat

N/C

NS

0.017

N/C

NS

N/C

NS

79.4

 

20.6

Teatskin

***

-

NS

NS

NS

NS

dim6P = 0.003

7.2

21.1

71.7

Wounds

-

-

0.020

0.025

NS

NS

NS

26.0

 

74.0

Warts

NS

-

NS

NS

NS

NS

dim2 P = 0.009

19.6

 

80.4

Wounds warts

***

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

5.1

 

94.9

Warts -tip

***

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

15.3

 

84.7

Teatend callus

-

-

-

NS

NS

0.020

dim6 P = 0.019

7.4

44.3

48.3

Scar

N/C

NS

N/C

N/C

N/C

N/C

NS

71.1

 

28.9

Hardness

N/C

NS

NS

N/C

NS

N/C

NS

46.7

 

53.3

  1. Obs = observer
  2. Dim = days in milk
  3. Par = parity
  4. *** P < 0.001
  5. '- 'signifies significant interaction with other parameter, value not relevant
  6. N/C – non convergence of model
  7. NS – not significant